Thursday, December 09, 2010

Envision Laie.... Running Out of Inventory


I've been putting off doing this post for a couple days because it takes so much energy for me to "gather" my thoughts. This is my personal opinion and not a personal attack on your opinion. Agreed? That means that I'm not criticizing your opinion so don't take it personal!


December 7th, Helbert Hastert & Fee Planners (on behalf of the City & County of Honolulu) held a meeting at Kahuku High School and opened the forum up to the public for commentary on the proposed Envision Laie expansion. I haven't put a great deal of time into researching Envision Laie specifically. I don't think a person really needs to do the in depth research to oppose it. In the opposite direction, if you did do the in depth research to find a reason to support it, I think you'd find that there's no basis for supporting it.

Let me set up what I think are pertinent facts to the ongoing controversy.

  • The current plan for Ko'olau Loa (pdf document of the actual plan) does not include expansion of Malaekahana.
  • Hawaii Reserves Inc. (HRI) manages property for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, which means all of La'ie.
  • In 2003, HRI purchased Malaekahana and began the planning process for "Envision Laie".
The current City and County of Honolulu sustainability plan for Ko'olau Loa wishes to preserve the agriculture land and preservations land. In fact, it seeks to develop agriculture rather than build houses. 

There are several guidelines that must be followed when dealing with the City and County of Honolulu and other governmental agencies. There are specific procedures in place. In the case of Envision Laie's proposed expansion of La'ie, their proposal was never a part of the City's plan. Envision Laie is seeking to extend the deadline for proposed changes to the City plan and eventually amend the City plan to include the expansion of La'ie. A good example of a well-executed City plan is Kapolei whose proposed development was many decades in the making.

The meeting held on December 7th was just one in a series of several public opinion meetings. SIDENOTE: I must say that I am grateful that my community is so passionate about the future of our ahupua'a. Every single meeting I have attended in regards to this issue has been standing-room-only. At the heart of the argument is HRI is petitioning the City to first, convert ag land into residential. Second, "permit" them to begin construction (by amending the City plan). The opposition prefers that the City maintain its current stance of preserving ag land. 

HRI and Envision Laie was very clever in that they hired a mainland marketing firm (rather than an economic development firm) to push forward their development plan. Several sources point out this fact. I think it is a valid point to consider in determining an opinion on the issues. 

Some of the points I have gathered from sitting in on several of the Envision Laie meetings are as follows:
  • Proposed construction of over a thousand new homes and condo's
  • Proposed new shopping center
  • Expansion of BYU-HAWAII
  • Full expansion of Turtle Bay that was previously struck from the City plan based on community opposition
I don't know why La'ie community members are enamored with this plan. What is attractive about more houses and more hotels? At the meeting, I was so taken aback by the community members who support Envision Laie. They did not give me one valid reason for the expansion. Many testified that they wanted this to go through for their kids. What exactly does that mean? Many said that additional housing is moving toward sustainability. Last I checked, houses can't be eaten. BYU students testified that they didn't have anywhere to live. Fluff!

I really could go on and on about this topic and maybe I will revisit it in the future. For me, HRI/ Envision Laie cares only for the interests of the LDS Church. (Yes, I am LDS and No, I don't have to follow blindly.) It is HRI's right to protect their interests. I just get all irritated with community members who have effectively been "sold" the plan without really truly thinking about how sustainable the plan is or isn't. Most supporters like the idea of "affordable" housing. A thousand homes will go very fast. Then what? What will be the next proposal? Will it still be "affordable" after the inventory is gone? How does HRI plan to impose a measure where 50% of the homes will go to community members? Isn't housing discrimination illegal?

I am just NOT SOLD on this plan and I haven't even touched on the economics of Envision Laie or the imposition of colonial practices onto the host culture of these islands. Maybe that will be another post. I just can't see the long term benefit of the development of La'ie.  

Sources:

4 comments:

IWA (e - va) said...

After the fist couple Envision Laie meeting, I came away thinking that what they were "selling" wasnt for me. And the way that they proposed it to the community irritated me. I didnt feel like they {Envision Laie) wanted our input at all, i felt like they were there to just make us feel good about home ownership (which almost no could probably afford at this time) so that we would all support "THEIR" vision not our vision.

I laughed when i heard BYUH students testifying.... uh to what? haha!

Live Well, Laugh Often, Love Much said...

I'm with you on this. I really don't want to see that community change. I love driving past Gunstock ranch. It is very symbolic for me of visiting my Grandparents every Sunday. Gunstock Ranch would mean that we were getting closer to their house. Of course now, they are gone but this is a memory that I hold on to and I'm reminded of whenever we drive past.

This is just one of many reasons I don't want to see "Envision Laie" take place. Here are some others

Reasons to oppose:
-Traffic congestion
-overcrowding of schools
-can't even control flooding and they want to expand?
-land preservation
-like the small hometown feel.

Independent Kama'aina said...

The following reader’s comment after the article is atrocious revelation about Envision Laie. DAMN! The high maka maka must think Laie is full of stupid heathens. LOL.

http://www.hawaiibusiness.com/Hawaii-Business/January-2010/Should-the-Envision-Laie-Project-be-Built/

“ ... In one of my jobs, I had the priviledge of serving a long time supporter of the community a BYU/PCC board member’s wife. She came into the facility I worked in and we had a brief conversation about the development ideas of Laie, out of respect of others opinions I didn’t comment. End of the conversation, she smiled and said “You know if we build it better people will come and live there.” Shocked, I could not believe I heard it. Better people? What better people??

Mona IkaKoula said...

*applauds Well said...and I totally agree...its all about MONEY...HRI lost focus on what's really important...and who the heck are the BYU students to even have a say in any of it...it should ONLY be the LOCALs OF THE LAIE COMMUNITY that have anything to say about Envision Laie. It makes me SICK.